Resolution of stock structure of toothfish in Australian and other waters is required. Tagging experiments, while important, cannot by themselves give a complete picture of stock structure. If genetic differences between areas are detected, then the amount of gene flow between areas must be minimal and more than one stock can be assumed. However, if differences are not detected, then the hypothesis of a single genetic stock cannot be rejected. This hypothesis may be rejected if there is no evidence from tagging experiments of fish movement between areas. Therefore, resolution of stock structure is better managed by a combination of tagging and genetic approaches than by either approach alone. Tagging experiments are under way; we propose to carry out the required genetic analyses, and then consider both sets of data jointly to define likely stock structures.
Genetic evidence already collected (based on small sample sizes from two areas of Macquarie), suggests that the amount of movement between fishing locations might be very limited. If this preliminary conclusion is substantiated by larger sample sizes, then careful management of the fishery will be needed, as depletion of one area is unlikely to be quickly replaced by immigration from another area.
The work proposed here will resolve this issue for Macquarie island, and will also determine whether there are separable substocks of toothfish around HIMI, and whether the HIMI stock(s) are separable from the Macquarie island stock(s). Importantly, if William's Ridge fish are identified as part of a straddling stock extending into Australia's EEZ (Heard Island), then they can be managed as though wholly part of Australia's EEZ (recent UNIA agreement).
These issues have to be resolved for effective and sustainable management of toothfish fisheries by Australian management (AFMA). The information gathered will also be relevant to the management authorities of other nations controlling toothfish fisheries.
Note: Recent meetings of CCAMLR (1998, 1999) have recognised the urgent requirement of further work on stock structure in D. eleginoides , particularly as initial genetic studies in other laboratories using isolectric focussing and allozyme analysis have reported inconsistent results (see Box 1 below).
